top of page
Election-Accountability-Project-logo
Type 'EAP Election Challenge'
as the Honoree Name 

Type '2024 Election Challenge'

as the Honoree Name

Now: The Current Election

Continuing the Work of Accountable Elections

Our civil case to preserve the ballots was appealed all the way to the CA Supreme Court but the court did not rule in our favor and the ballots were destroyed.

During this election, we are carrying that work forward—following the paperwork in real time and legally prepared to file an election challenge during this canvass period. 

We know their playbook now. 

01 — Monitor

Observe election procedures, ballot handling, and reconciliation as this election unfolds.

02 — Document

Public records requests; Quality controls; Processes that follow CA election code

03 — Engage

Donate to our legal fund; encourage participation, and hold officials accountable through public channels.

Why file a civil case?

When the Attorney General fought the sheriff's investigation into these election inconsistencies, we knew if was time for the people to stand up and do something.

 

The Election Accountability Project asked the Riverside County Superior Court to stop the destruction of election records while a legal question about ballot reconciliation is decided. And account for the discrepancies found in the citizen audits. 

​

We are not contesting an election.

We are asking that the evidence still exist when the question is answered.

​

Case: Election Accountability Project, Inc. v. Art Tinoco, in his official capacity as Riverside County Registrar of Voters;

 

County of Riverside Filed: August 24, 2026, Riverside County Superior Court

 

Counsel: Alexander H. Haberbush, Constitutional Counsel Group

About the Civil Case

Donations for the lawsuit are

TAX DEDUCTIBLE!

Ultimately, answer the Question:

  • Direct the Registrar to perform, complete, or demonstrate the reconciliation required by Elections Code section 15302, sufficient to account for and explain the identified variances

  • Declare that a reconciliation confined to internally consistent electronic records, without accounting for the conflicting physical ballot records, does not satisfy the statute

  • If that reconciliation identifies a recurring deficiency, require the County to correct it before administering future elections under the same procedures

What we did not ask for:

  • No change to any certified election result

  • No recount, decertification, or reopening of any election

  • No custody, inspection, or opening of any ballot by EAP

  • No claim that fraud occurred, that unlawful ballots were counted, or that any result was wrong

What we asked the court to do: 
 

Immediately Preserve the Evidence

  • Prohibit the destruction, deletion, alteration, or overwriting of records needed to reconcile ballot receipt, processing, accounting, and counting in the November 2024 General Election and the November 2025 Special Election

  • Require any sealed ballot packages to remain in the exclusive custody of election officials, unopened and unaltered

  • Require the County to provide a verified inventory, within 10 days, of what records exist, where they are kept, their scheduled destruction dates, and whether any have already been destroyed

Riverside County Election Investigation Civil Petition 

Supreme Court Building

Election Accountability Project files petition with the CA Supreme Court

Supreme court filing.png

Case Info

Case: Election Accountability Project, Inc. v. Art Tinoco, in his official capacity as Riverside County Registrar of Voters; County of Riverside

 

Case No.: CVRI2605236 Court: Riverside County Superior Court, Department 4 — Hon. Daniel Ottolia Filed: August 24, 2026

 

Counsel: Alexander H. Haberbush, Constitutional Counsel Group

Purpose

California law requires county election officials to reconcile their ballot records as part of every official canvass. Public records from two Riverside County elections show large differences between ballots counted and ballots reflected as received — differences that have not been explained.

​

The Election Accountability Project asked the Riverside County Superior Court to require that reconciliation, and to preserve the records needed to perform it before they are destroyed.

​

On August 25, 2026, the court granted a temporary restraining order preserving the records and issued an order to show cause regarding a preliminary injunction.

What the citizen audits found:

Volunteers in Riverside County developed a strict audit process and compared the County's published certified totals against the County's own ballot intake records — vote center ballot statements, vote-by-mail collection forms, and daily mail intake sheets — and subtracted the ballots the County reported as received but not counted.

​

A variance in one election might come from an isolated clerical error or a particular reporting convention. A materially similar variance in a second election run by the same office under the same procedures raises a different question: whether something in the process itself is producing it.

​

The full audit reports are linked HERE:

​

Where the case stands today:

Sept 24, 2026 UPDATE;

Sheriff Chad Bianco's case at the CA Supreme Court regarding this same evidence was decided on today. He is required to follow the supervision of the Attorney General Rob Bonta on any investigations (Bonta v Bianco). And he must return the ballots to the Registrar (Cervantes v Bianco). He may keep other election material.

 

Sept 21 EAP filed at the CA Supreme Court a petition for review and to request a stay

​

Sept 16 Appeals court denied EAP the writ of mandate and request for immediate stay to preserve the ballots

​

Sept  14 EAP filed an appeal with the CA Appeals Court

​

Sept 10 Hearing in Superior Court-Judge Ottolia approved the Registrar's petition to destroy the 2024 and 2025 ballots and denied the writ of mandate.

​

On August 25, 2026, the court granted EAP's application for a temporary restraining order and an order to show cause regarding a preliminary injunction. The ex parte hearing scheduled for the following morning was vacated as no longer necessary.

​

Riverside County has since applied to vacate the temporary restraining order. A hearing on the County's application is set for September 10, 2026.

​

A hearing on the amount of the undertaking and on the briefing schedule for the order to show cause is set for September 28, 2026. A status hearing on the writ petition is set for November 2, 2026.

​

The temporary restraining order preserves records. It does not change any election result, and it does not give EAP access to any ballot.

​

​

California requires county election officials to conduct an official canvass after every election, and Elections Code section 15302 says that canvass "shall include, but not be limited to" a series of specified tasks.

 

Three of them are reconciliations:

  • Subdivision (b): the number of signatures on the roster, reconciled with the number of ballots recorded on the ballot statement

  • Subdivision (c): if that comparison shows a discrepancy, ballots received from each polling place, reconciled with ballots cast as indicated on the ballot statement

  • Subdivision (d): ballots counted, spoiled, canceled, or invalidated, reconciled with the votes recorded by the vote-counting system, including vote-by-mail and provisional ballots

 

Notice the structure. Every one of these compares records of different kinds. Paper against machine. Signatures against statements. Ballots received against ballots counted.

​

That is the point. The paper records created as ballots arrive and are processed — rosters, ballot statements, collection forms, mail intake sheets — exist as an independent check on the totals the electronic system produces. A comparison confined to records the counting system generated about itself would be internally consistent and would verify nothing.

​

The California Legislature has described the duties associated with completing and certifying election results as "ministerial and nondiscretionary." They are not optional.

bottom of page